Images + graphs : the winning persuasion combination

Posted on November 27, 2006. Filed under: Animation, conference, English, Video |

Have you seen Davis Guggenheim’s documentary “An Inconvenient Truth” (“Une vérité qui dérange” en Français) ? The latest docu-blockbuster showcases Al Gore’s crusade to raise the world’s awareness on the global climate crisis is a powerful example of the use of visual information to convince viewers of the reality of its key aspects, like the raising levels of carbon dioxyde.

Some of this borrows from the best of Hollywood craftmanship or Pentagon’s psychological operations toolbox … this time for a good cause ! I was convinced long before the film that man could have an effect on global environment issues but like others I had trouble with the fact that many climate scientists admit they could not prove the rising carbon level was truly causing sea level or temperature to increase. The case made by the novel “State of Fear” (“Etat d’urgence” en Français) from Michael Crichton was quite persuasive in its own sense … one could not win a legal case on this issue ! But to Al Gore’s credit, his slideshow really moves mountains : as the famous French photograph Yann Arthus-Bertrand put it during the conference that followed the showing, he has been trying for 10 years to no avail to convince some of his friends who were turned around by the film !

The most convincing part is probably the rapid succession of graphs going through the roof and video images of hurricanes, floods, tsunamis, … As well as superimposing 2 graphs to show the evidence without having to prove it.

Rising carbon and temperature levels

To those who see PowerPoint as evil … Al Gore’s slideshow will prove hard to fight in the minds of all who saw it ! The video images speak to the emotional self, while the graphs speak to the rational self. In the minds of most people graphs can not lie as they represent hard facts that can be traced back to a source that can be challenged by experts, whom they trust to voice their disagreement if it is wrong. But in our information overloaded society such a disagreement will be hard to hear … and to weigh against contradictive analyses / opinions.

Addition : I recently found another example (that may have been to some extent ‘inspired’ by Al Gore’s) : a lesson in economics (amongst other things showing the impact of the level of taxes on growth) by the the Medef’s president Laurence Parisot at the last General Assembly in January.

Pedagogie economique par L. Parisot
Uploaded by besoindair


Make a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

One Response to “Images + graphs : the winning persuasion combination”

RSS Feed for Uswim : You See What I Mean ? Comments RSS Feed

[…] As I said earlier (see here and here), visual language is more "universal" than verbal language, but of course this is mostly true for some forms of visual language such as icons, pictos, graphs / matrix, schemas, and some more recent forms. This is far from being the case yet for photographs and colors (direct representation of nature), which signification can differ considerably from one culture to another … even if a certain convergence can be observed. […]

Where's The Comment Form?

Liked it here?
Why not try sites on the blogroll...

%d bloggers like this: